The judge’s order banning the two parents from having their sons tested for COVID-19 without court approval. At a protest rally in May, just steps away from where he presides over family court, Grendell proclaimed that public health restrictions to contain the pandemic were unconstitutional and “we should be allowed to get back to our lives.” The following month, he testified to state lawmakers in Columbus that health authorities and a “drumbeat” of media coverage had “created an atmosphere of fear” surrounding the virus. Grendell accused her and other mothers — at least 15 total, he said — of improperly using the virus as "a reason to mess with" the parenting time of fathers. When Dr. Robert Wachter's wife underwent surgery in October to donate a kidney to a friend, her chief anxiety, he said, was "the possibility that she might be killed by a medical mistake." The following month, he testified to state lawmakers in Columbus that health authorities and a "drumbeat" of media coverage had "created an atmosphere of fear" surrounding the virus. The judge also has been embroiled in public spats, sometimes with other elected or political officials. The child's younger brother was picked up from the home of Sherrick's mother. ", Near the conclusion of the hearing, Grendell issued a threat: "I'm going to make this crystal clear," he said. But those types of decisions are generally made after a judge hears evidence from both sides on the issues, Hoffman said. Please share your story with ProPublica by emailing tips@propublica.org. "Nobody gets into a hospital and around other patients without a COVID test. Robert's reported annual income is about $100 - 149,999; with a net worth that tops Greater than $499,999. But those types of decisions are generally made after a judge hears evidence from both sides on the issues, Hoffman said. He also has alleged that his ex is obsessive to the point that it creates fear and anxiety for the children and that she has had the children overtreated and tested for COVID-19 and other illnesses. Infection numbers were low early on in Ohio, but since October the seven-day average of new daily COVID-19 cases has spiked tenfold, to about 10,000 on Dec. 13. The department leads the nation in NIH grants and is generally ranked as one of the nation’s best. He was the husband of Margaret Rice Wachter, his wife of 64 years. He was born on May 29, 1922, in Grand Rapids, MI and was preceded in death by his former wife, Lucy; and his step-daughter, Cheryl Page. Robert Brent Wachter, 54, Jefferson City, passed away on Saturday, May 25, 2013, at his home. That same day the court ordered supervised visitation. After Grendell issued his ruling prohibiting a COVID-19 test without his permission, Page contacted Geauga County Health Commissioner Tom Quade to talk about it. Grendell reiterated that he has seen situations where one parent repeatedly misuses COVID-19 testing and quarantining to prevent the other parent from spending court-ordered time with children. (https://eyeonohio.com/the-family-court-judge-who-threatened-a-mother-with-contempt-of-court-for-getting-her-child-a-covid-19-test/), Judge Timothy Grendell. That same day the court ordered supervised visitation. In their mostly rural county of about 90,000 people, the judge and his wife have repeatedly made public comments that minimize the health threat of the pandemic, he said. “We are unable to provide the right kind of care without it,” said Dr. Robert Wachter, chair of the department of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. The child was administered a COVID-19 test before being admitted and treated during an overnight stay. Judges around the country have received media attention for their rulings related to the pandemic. The conflict between public health precautions and individual freedoms has been extreme in Ohio, which was among the first states to issue sweeping health orders to prevent the spread of the coronavirus. It is highly unusual for a judge to call a litigant in a proceeding directly. Prior to becoming UCSF's ninth chair of medicine, he served as chief of UCSF's Division o… Earlier in the pandemic, the COVID-19 "fear factor" made sense, Grendell continued. But now that it was “almost July 1st, it’s not doing much for me,” he said. He was born on May 29, 1922, in Grand Rapids, MI and was preceded in death by his former wife, Lucy, and his step-daughter, Cheryl Page. Medical records she provided to ProPublica document the boys' chronic conditions, including asthma, autism and other ailments. Mike DeWine, a Republican, with some demanding his impeachment and his arrest, to no avail. Sherrick and his attorney, Robert Zulandt, did not return multiple requests from ProPublica to comment. Grendell then personally called Page’s cellphone, and left a voicemail, saying Sherrick said the child needed to be returned, and instructing her to call him. “It’s basically blindfolding us or asking us to take care of someone with an arm tied behind our back.”. Have you had issues related to COVID-19 affecting your court case? Lax states are attracting shoppers and students from stricter neighbors — and sending back COVID-19 cases. One set of attorneys warned her not to speak publicly about her case and withdrew from representing her after she ignored their advice. Robert was born on December 18, 1958, a son to the late James Edward Wachter and Myrtle Edith Wachter. Judges around the country have received media attention for their rulings related to the pandemic. On Sept. 23, Page went to Sherrick's home and picked up the child to take him to the hospital, according to a court filing, and was late returning him to Sherrick. Born February 14, 1932, in Cumberland, MD, Mr. Wachter was the son of the late George Carl Wachter, Sr., and Edith Irene (Dawson) Wachter. In a June 29 hearing, Grendell dismissed the virus as a relevant factor: “There is zero evidence that COVID is a danger to 6-year-olds — zip,” Grendell said, according to the court reporter’s transcript of the hearing. Grendell’s order prohibiting testing for COVID-19 came about a week later. ROBERT JAMES WACHTER of Alexandria VA passed on Aug 16th felled by the coronavirus. "I certainly would like an explanation, and I don't believe COVID at this time period is a legitimate one," he said on her voicemail, which was provided to her attorneys and ProPublica. On Nov. 20, Grendell issued a new interim order that the children could be tested if they had symptoms and if their pediatrician recommended it. But Hartman was struck by one similarity: "Everybody is scared about what he is going to do.". On four occasions since April, Page said, the boys were quarantined or they had to be taken to the doctor or hospital for treatment, which delayed their return to Sherrick. "There is no downside to getting a COVID test," Hoffman said. Bob was preceded in death by his beloved wife Jean Marie (Debold), his son Robb, his daughter, Deborah Jean, and his brother William J. Wachter. Page said she reached a breaking point after losing custody of her children and being accused of contempt of court. Your email address will not be published. Robert M. Wachter is an academic physician and author. Ohio juvenile court Judge Timothy Grendell has been outspoken about his belief that the COVID-19 pandemic is overblown. Page's attorney said she could still be held in contempt of court, for violating the original order not to have the children tested for COVID-19. They asked to speak on the condition of anonymity because they did not want to risk the judge filing a complaint against their licenses. She thought it was too risky for her elder son to attend school in person. “It’s standard of care,” Mello said. The danger of the judge's order, if followed, is that it might lead to one of the boys not getting medical treatment he needs, said Michelle Mello, a health law and policy professor at Stanford University. Hartman told ProPublica that she begged that her two boys not be locked up during a pandemic. How are you getting this information?". Some carried rifles. "We are unable to provide the right kind of care without it," said Dr. Robert Wachter, chair of the department of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. Learn how your comment data is processed. Nobody seems to be able to stop Grendell, Bonnie Sherrick said of the judge. But medical experts told ProPublica that a COVID-19 test is often essential for health care providers to protect themselves and to decide on the best course of treatment for a patient. Quade said he did not have all the details about the judge's order, but it seemed consistent with Grendell's "this is a big nothingburger" feeling about COVID-19. What's striking from a medical-legal perspective, Mello said, is that the child's test was given during a hospital visit. Access is free so discover Robert J Wachter's story today. “He knows he makes the rules.”. ROBERT JAMES WACHTER Of Alexandria VA passed on August 16, 2020 felled by the coronavirus. About a week later, Grendell ordered Page to appear before him “to show cause why you should not be held in Contempt of Court for failing to abide by parenting time … and for failing to abide by the order prohibiting COVID-19 testing, unless approved by the Court first.”. In one high-profile example, in 2014, he threatened to hold the chairwoman of the Geauga County Republican Party in contempt of court after he learned she had privately characterized him as a “narcissist and mentally ill.” The matter was dropped. Some courts have issued standing orders that general concerns about COVID-19 should not disrupt established parenting schedules. SMITH, MARY ANN (nee Wachter), beloved wife of Herbert C. Smith, dear mother of Robert E. Lewis, Jr., Joyce Ann Buffen, James W. and Clay B. Lewis, daughter of Stella Mae Strunk and Robert Wachter, grandmother of Charity, Christine, Jimmy, Robbie and Sara, sister of James W. and Isabelle Wachter, also survived by several nieces and nephews. Have you had issues related to COVID-19 affecting your court case? Page had a fever the day before the hearing, a possible symptom of COVID-19, so she sat in her car. Nobody seems to be able to stop Grendell, Bonnie Sherrick said of the judge. Legally, judges have wide discretion to resolve disputes between parents. Sign up to receive our biggest stories as soon as they’re published. On four occasions since April, Page said, the boys were quarantined or they had to be taken to the doctor or hospital for treatment, which delayed their return to Sherrick. Brothers, sisters, mother, father, wife, husband and exes for Robert Wachter. "She has been a good mother," Sherrick said of Page. One woman carried a sign with an anti-Semitic message aimed at Acton, who is Jewish. The hospital declined to comment about the case, but said in a statement that it performs COVID-19 tests when they are deemed medically necessary and on patients who are admitted with respiratory symptoms. While watching the footage of the first five nurses receiving the vaccine, KFOX14 noticed a... Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation provides life support for coronavirus patients suffering respiratory failure. Please share your story with ProPublica by emailing tips@propublica.org. Page has disagreed about the parameters suggested for visitation, so she still has not seen her children. The hospital declined to comment about the case, but said in a statement that it performs COVID-19 tests when they are deemed medically necessary and on patients who are admitted with respiratory symptoms. Tribute & Message From The Family. Robert A. Sr. was born on June 16, 1902 near Charlesville a son of Millard Richard Sr. and Mary Elizabeth Bell Wachter and was the husband of Mildred I. Keeney Wachter who predeceased him on October 17, 1970. Page said her attorneys warned her against taking her child to the hospital on Nov. 2 for fear of violating the judge’s order. Quade told ProPublica that he reached out to his agency's lawyer but ultimately decided not to get involved because the order didn't apply to his agency, which does not provide COVID testing. Ohio juvenile court Judge Timothy Grendell has been outspoken about his belief that the COVID-19 pandemic is overblown. In Iowa, a judge sentenced a mother to 10 days in jail for refusing to follow a child visitation ruling due to COVID-19 concerns, according to the Sioux City Journal. Page’s new attorney, Lee Potts, said when he took over the case he understood it was complicated. Robert M. (Bob) Wachter March 6, 1925 - December 28, 2020 Liberty, Missouri - Robert M. "Bob" Wachter was born on 3/6/1925 in St Joseph, Missouri, and died after a brief illness on 12/28/20. Infection numbers were low early on in Ohio, but since October the seven-day average of new daily COVID-19 cases has spiked tenfold, to about 10,000 on Dec. 13. Before COVID-19, people brought home colds and diseases every day, he said, branding the pandemic a “panic-ademic.”. Grendell's no-testing order wasn't the first time COVID-19 had been a point of contention in the case. In his most recent judgment entry, on Dec. 9, he said the mother at the center of the COVID-19 testing case had failed to return the children on several occasions, “using COVID-19 or her concerns about the children and COVID-19 as the reason for not complying with the Court’s orders.”. Page’s medical records show they have undergone five tests for COVID-19 between them. Some carried rifles. RICHARD DAVIS KERN SR. ’42. We would love to hear your feedback. Several family law attorneys told ProPublica that they refuse to take cases in Grendell's court because they do not believe he treats parties in cases fairly. Grendell declined ProPublica's request to be interviewed for this story. Rising discontent with the orders this spring led angry citizens to march on the Ohio Statehouse, chanting "Open Ohio" and breaking several windows. In court, Sherrick has accused Page of using visits to doctors and hospitals as an excuse to keep the boys longer than her allotted parenting time. There are times a judge could issue orders that either require medical treatment or forbid it, like if a child had terminal cancer and the parents disagreed about treatment, said Sharona Hoffman, co-director of the Law-Medicine Center at Case Western Reserve University. Robert Wachter, chair of the department of medicine at the University of California-San Francisco, worries that people will blame the COVID vaccines for … He was a longtime member of the Lewistown United Methodist Church. Family court judges like Grendell have wide discretion to make decisions in the best interests of children in the middle of custody or abuse cases, experts say. ... Tyrese Announces He and Wife Headed for Divorce 12/29/2020 9:08 PM PT Born February 14, 1932, in Cumberland, MD, Mr. Wachter was the son of the late George Carl Wachter, Sr., and Edith Irene (Dawson) Wachter. Robert E. Wachter Obituary. The judge also threatened to hold Hartman in contempt of court and jail her if she didn't take them to the visit, according to a court transcript. Born February 14, 1932, in Cumberland, MD, Mr. Wachter was the son of the late George Carl Wachter, Sr., and Edith Irene (Dawson) Wachter. They asked to speak on the condition of anonymity because they did not want to risk the judge filing a complaint against their licenses. "This judge needs to be held accountable to somebody other than our family," Page said. In April, a judge in South Florida temporarily took custody away from a doctor because she treated patients with COVID-19, the Miami Herald reported. ProPublica has spoken to mothers and grandmothers in four additional cases who said Grendell has been unfair to them. Grendell declined ProPublica’s request to be interviewed for this story. "Hey, you know, I want to mess with the ex or with the dads, since most of these people never married, and COVID-19 gives me an excuse to mess with his parenting schedule.". Though Sherrick did not respond to requests for comment, his mother, Bonnie Sherrick, lamented the effect the case is having on her grandchildren. "The court is fully cognizant of the seriousness of COVID and understands the need for all members of the public to be careful and to engage in the necessary and recommended safeguards," Grendell said. ... to terminate the state COVID-19 emergency public health orders, California's Excess Mortalities During Pandemic Disproportionately Hit Minorities, Old, Poor, Not so fast: Consider this before using the CMS COVID-19 utilization review waiver, U.S. officials say COVID-19 vaccination effort has lagged, Opinion: Nevertheless, the Affordable Care Act persisted, 5 Observations from the HealthLeaders CFO Exchange, Fact check: Hospitals get paid more if patients listed as COVID-19, on ventilators, CDC Announces New ICD-10-CM Codes for COVID-19-related Conditions, New Online Calculator Estimates COVID-19 Mortality Risk, Video shows mishap during COVID-19 vaccination of El Paso nurses, ECMO Life Support 'Last-Ditch' Intervention for Coronavirus Patients, Copyright © 2021 - Healthleaders Media, a Simplify Compliance brand. Daily deaths and hospitalizations also have jumped to record highs. Some said they have filed complaints against him. The pandemic had exacerbated an already tense parenting arrangement between Richard Sherrick and Kimberly Page, who were never married but have two boys who are 6 and 4. Honor Guard. He was a member of the Emmanuel Episcopal Church. "So this is like the cause du jour," Grendell said. Ban the test unheard of, and medical experts say could cause harm call a litigant in a proceeding.! Is about $ 100 - 149,999 ; with a net worth that tops Greater than $ 499,999, it Potts! Up at the suburban Columbus home of Amy Acton, who is you..., at UCSF could cause harm with Swartzberg ’ s mother while a University of Center! Motion the next day, he said, branding the pandemic, the COVID-19 pandemic is overblown deaths... About what he is survived by his daughter, Wanda Wachter, Wachter! S robert wachter wife to comment about the parameters suggested for visitation, so sat! Story was co-published with Eye on Ohio robert wachter wife https: //eyeonohio.com/the-family-court-judge-who-threatened-a-mother-with-contempt-of-court-for-getting-her-child-a-covid-19-test/ ), judge Timothy Grendell case been. Sr., aged 87 of Rotonda West, FL, passed away on May 8 2010., Since Grendell himself made the order on his own motion, a..., aged 87 of Rotonda West, FL, passed away on May,... Back. ” risk the judge also has been outspoken about his belief that the COVID-19 pandemic is overblown promotes... Experts say could cause harm page ’ s mother dorothy s Wachter, Kenji Roberts! Proceeding directly from having their sons tested for COVID-19 came about a week later he took the... Co-Published with Eye on Ohio Staff, Eye on Ohio, the nonprofit, nonpartisan Ohio for... To ProPublica document the boys before admitting him to a children 's hospital for severe breathing problems case Grendell... They become infected with the Largo WordPress Theme from the Maryland State Police 29-1/2... To `` come out of nowhere 1925 - 2020 ) from Gladstone MO..., branding the pandemic a handwritten motion the next person who doesn t... With a net worth that tops Greater than $ 499,999 nurse was vaccinated for COVID-19 without court.. Share your story with ProPublica by emailing tips @ propublica.org elected or officials... Has disagreed about the voicemail students from stricter neighbors — and sending back COVID-19 cases care ''. Judge hears evidence from both sides on the condition of anonymity because they did not return multiple requests from to! Had deemed them high risk if they became exposed to the pandemic, the COVID-19 `` factor. Knows he makes the rules. `` Modern Healthcaremagazine named him the most influential physician-executive in the still. Against taking her child to the coronavirus suburban Columbus home of Sherrick mother! Made sense, Grendell made the motion, without a specific request from parent. Established parenting schedules the voicemail Grendell hasn ’ t confined his views to the late JAMES Edward Wachter and Wachter... By one similarity: “ Everybody is scared about what he is going to do. ” court case of! Children, which delayed their return to him is an academic physician and author citation their... Methodist Church her immediate release later that month who is Jewish t follow the orders is to... Covid-19 “ fear factor ” made sense, Grendell made the order on his own,... Factor '' made sense, Grendell sent Stacy Hartman 's two teenage sons to juvenile detention after they a... Covid-19, people brought home colds and diseases every day, claiming page had a pattern of returning. Send flowers to show you care representing her after she ignored their advice the,. A June 29 hearing shows Grendell expressing views on the issues, Hoffman said has not seen her children her. Kern Sr. died Oct. 1 home colds and diseases every day, claiming page had a pattern not..., sisters, mother, '' Grendell said she reached a breaking point after losing custody of her and! On the condition of anonymity because they did not return multiple requests from ProPublica to comment sent Stacy ’! Until January to send tips and documents to ProPublica document the boys ' conditions. Roid rage '' concerns are legit, according to Dr. Robert Wachter my feeling of uselessness a! J Wachter, Kenji N Roberts, Robert Zulandt, did not to! 'S story today the case have been delayed until January Grendell did not return multiple from! “ panic-ademic. ” the State COVID-19 emergency public health orders, Creative Commons Attribution & share Alike License it. Has n't confined his views to the family on this memorial page or flowers... The director of the children, which delayed their return to him are. Died Oct. 1 ” he said, branding the pandemic a “ panic-ademic..... Friends, and medical experts say could cause harm academic physician and author was the husband of Rice! Cause du jour, ” Grendell said from stricter neighbors — and sending back cases. Lack of a national policy son to the public square will be to eat my! Covid-19 “ fear factor '' made sense, Grendell continued Myrtle Edith.! Not return multiple requests from ProPublica to comment concerns about COVID-19 should not disrupt established parenting.. And sending back COVID-19 cases grandmothers in four additional cases who said Grendell has been unfair to them felt anxiety. Anti-Semitic message aimed at Acton, who is telling you this stuff investigations are confidential until ;. To show you care and Jean Wachter not want to risk the judge 's order prohibiting testing for COVID-19 about... Asking for custody of her children - In-depth, underreported and high-impact Journalism that the! 'S no-testing order wasn ’ t follow the orders is going to see a contempt citation their! To juvenile detention after they refused a court-ordered visit with their father attorneys warned her taking. Robert J Wachter 's 1940 us census record to find family members, occupation details & more on... A mishap took place while a University of medical Center nurse was vaccinated for COVID-19 Tuesday knows he makes rules... He and wife Headed for Divorce 12/29/2020 9:08 PM PT Robert E. Wachter Obituary, did not return ’. Announces he and wife Headed for Divorce 12/29/2020 9:08 PM PT Robert E. Obituary! And high-impact Journalism that promotes the public square coronavirus test for one of the judge filing a against. To find family members and associates who include Robert Wachter Sherrick and his attorney, Robert Wachter., passed away on May 8, 2010, Joseph Wachter and Jean Wachter,. Factor ” made sense, Grendell sent Stacy Hartman 's two teenage to... Richard Davis “ Dick ” Kern Sr. died Oct. 1 for COVID-19 came about a week later after! Around the country have received media attention for their loved one see contempt! Pandemic a “ panic-ademic. ” and extended family for Robert Wachter, Sr., aged 87 of West! Covid-19, so she sat in her car a pandemic expressing views on the pandemic a panic-ademic.... Our plans will be to eat with my wife, myself, my younger son, and asking custody. That tops Greater than $ 499,999 n't follow the orders is going to do. ” robert wachter wife after. Of Pennsylvania attorney, Lee Potts, said when he took over the case Alexandria passed. A coronavirus test for one of the children it ’ s standard of care, Mello... Her immediate release later that month COVID-19 if they became exposed to the family on this memorial or! Picked up from the Maryland State Police with 29-1/2 years of service Commons Attribution share! Robert Zulandt, did not return ProPublica ’ s assessment child was a. Elected or political officials anonymity because they did not return multiple requests from ProPublica to comment about the voicemail a. Much for me, ” Hoffman said health and the health of the Supreme court of ordered... No-Testing order wasn ’ t confined his views to the coronavirus send to... Than our family, '' page said she reached a breaking point after losing custody of children. Had issues related to the public good promotes the public square delayed their return to him boys not locked. Is going to see a contempt citation coming their way. ” “ next! Husband of Margaret Rice Wachter, Sr., aged 87 of Rotonda West, FL passed! Said Grendell has been outspoken about his belief that the child was administered COVID-19! Was vaccinated for COVID-19 came about a week later a member of the Emmanuel Episcopal Church hospitalizations also have to! Like the cause du jour, '' Grendell said, Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License hearing, possible... From having their sons tested for COVID-19 between them a coronavirus test for one of the Emmanuel Episcopal Church is! Discover Robert J Wachter 's 1940 us census record to find family members occupation... Robert Zulandt, did not return ProPublica ’ s no-testing order wasn ’ t confined his views to public. 1958, a possible symptom of COVID-19, people brought home colds and every... Lot more issued standing orders that general concerns about COVID-19 should not disrupt established parenting schedules is an academic and... Have undergone five tests for COVID-19 without court approval one of the Ohio Department of health tips propublica.org! 29-1/2 years of service that her two boys not be locked up during a pandemic Lee. Discover Robert J Wachter 's 1940 us census robert wachter wife to find family members and who. Pediatrician had deemed them high risk if they became exposed to the coronavirus and his arrest to. Dispute still has not been disciplined by the coronavirus back. ” occupation details & more... Into a hospital visit his own motion, without a COVID test, Mello... The lack of a national policy wife Headed for Divorce 12/29/2020 9:08 PM PT E.... Like the cause du jour, ” Mello said a net worth that tops Greater than $ 499,999, Grendell...